Selecting the Right Tree

Selecting the Right Tree

Remember to consider soil and surroundings when choosing your next tree

By Jeremy Priest

Most of us know about proper tree planting procedures (if not, see the resources below), but did you know that one of the most important aspects of a tree’s success starts with selecting the right tree? Many times a homeowner will plant a tree without considering two very important aspects: soil type and growing space. The first step in tree planting should be evaluating your soil conditions to determine some basic aspects.

  • Soil pH: The cross timbers region has a range of pH from acidic to alkaline so it’s important to choose species fitting your soil. The more eastern species such as redbud, maples, southern pines, and red oaks are examples of species that generally prefer acidic soils.

    Red oak located under power lines on a poor soil type

    This red oak is an example of a poor species & location match. The soil at this site is alkaline, which is not ideal for the species. The combination of soil and stress from regular pruning, due to the power lines overhead, lead to the tree’s decline.

    Mesquite, Gambel oak, and Monterrey oak are species that generally prefer alkaline soils. Many popular tree species promoted nationally are not adapted to moderately alkaline soils found in the cross timbers.

  • Soil water and drainage: Coarse texture soils such as sand and silt do not retain much moisture, so upland sites with these soils often have drought tolerant species such as post oak or blackjack oak. If you have this type of soil, and cannot regularly water, consider planting drought tolerant species such as desert willow or live oak. Fine texture soils like clay can retain water to the point of harming the tree. Species adapted to poorly drained soils include eastern redcedar, cedar elm, baldcypress, and bur oak.

Remember to consider pH, water availability, and drainage all together. The next step is to determine how much space is available and what the purpose of the tree will be.

  • Small/ornamental: These trees mostly provide beauty or natural screening from surroundings. Crapemyrtle, desert willow, and Eve’s necklace are examples of ornamental trees.
  • Medium-size: These trees are generally narrow, may not grow as tall as canopy species, and often retain lower branches suitable for providing natural screening. Examples include magnolia, eastern redcedar, or exoctic pines such as Afghan pine.
  • Large/canopy: These species are the dominant trees on the landscape, providing shade and most of the environmental benefits provided by urban trees. Examples include the oak species (live, bur, chinkapin, or post), pecan, native pines, elms, and ash. These trees have a large canopy spread and often provide food for wildlife.

Each size of tree can provide a mix of beauty, screening/visibility, or shade. Consider planting a mix of not only different species, but tree sizes as well. There are lots of resources available on the web to educate and make for a successful tree planting.

U

Additional Information

A number of sites provide useful information for tree selection; see the list below for help with selecting a tree and learning more about your soil type. This is not a comprehensive list, there are many recommended tree species lists for North Texas out there so please research other sites as well.
Resources

Tree Selection Guide – Provided by the Texas A&M Forest Service

U.S. Soil Map – Web Soil Survey from the USDA NRCS

Fort Worth Recommended Tree List – The City of Fort Worth Native & Adapted Tree List

Urban Forest Information Sheets – Helpful information provided by the Texas A&M Forest Service

Tree Planting and Care – How to plant a tree from the City of Arlington

Citizen Foresters Plant Trees at Lake Grapevine

Citizen Foresters Plant Trees at Lake Grapevine

Citizen Foresters help with tree planting - Meadowmere Park

Citizen Foresters Melissa Carr (Denton), Karen Rice (Grapevine), and Bill Sargeant (Fort Worth) at the Meadowmere Tree Planting

On Saturday, November 12, 2017, three Citizen Foresters joined 27 other volunteers to plant 15 trees (sycamore, red oak, pecan, and dogwood) at the entrance area of Meadowmere Park, on Lake Grapevine.  This Grapevine Arbor Day event was hosted by Keep Grapevine Beautiful, a City of Grapevine agency.  High school and college students, along with parents, formed most of the participants. The weather on this cool and misty fall day was perfect for tree planting.

Volunteers use pickaxes to finish digging the last tree hole at Meadowmere Park.

Volunteers compete to finish digging the last tree hole.

The event culminated in the digging of a hole for planting the last tree: a sycamore. It was a friendly competition between girls and guys: the guys swinging a pick axe and girls handling shovels, both sweating it out to complete a two-foot-deep hole in the hard-caked soil (or perhaps it was rock?). By the time it was completed, both sides agreed it could not have been done without the team effort.